? Explanation of report features   View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Field strength:  Mean: 327 MP  Geomean: 74 MP
(based on 16 players)
★ ★ ★  Masterpoint Winners  ★ ★ ★
Partnership Pct Rank MP
Janet Schottle - Judi Swift 61.11 1st A 0.80
John Dusharme - Linda Dusharme 60.32 2nd A 0.56
Hideki Kitamura - Hiroko Kitamura 55.56 3rd A 0.40
Alice Hurley - Francie Collins 53.97 2nd C 0.17
EVENT>Thursday Afternoon Pairs |SESSION>Thursday Aft |SECTION> A
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>May 14, 2015       |CLUB NO.>260323    | 05/14/2015 15:48
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> Kathie Angione  |RATING>Club Masterpoint (100%, 70%, 60% Open)|MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   31.5 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>None/200/50    |CLUB>EASTLAKE BRIDGE CLUB
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=7/C=4                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Doral Hunter           John Peter Lagodimos     A    .     .     .     24.50  38.89          
 2 Gary Piazzoni          Elizabeth Piazzoni       B    .     .     .     32.50  51.59          
 3 Hiroko Kitamura        Hideki Kitamura          B    3     3     .     35.00  55.56  0.40(A) 
 4 Judi Swift             Janet Schottle           C    1     1     1     38.50  61.11  0.80(A) 
 5 Francie Collins        Alice Hurley             C    .     .     2     34.00  53.97  0.17(C) 
 6 Linda Dusharme         John Dusharme            B    2     2     .     38.00  60.32  0.56(A) 
 7 Marilyn Wolf           John Collins             C    .     .     .     27.00  42.86          
 8 Elisabeth Cogdill      Kathy Crail              C    .     .     .     22.50  35.71          
                                          Totals                         252.00       

1 ♠AQJ84
♥63
♦KQ
♣K954
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠T3
♥A82
♦A942
♣Q862
♠52
♥QJ954
♦J865
♣J3
♠K976
♥KT7
♦T73
♣AT7
15
105
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 3♠ 2NT  ♦6 ♥6
EW: 1♦ 1♥  ♣4 ♠4 NT4
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: +140 3♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          3.00   0.00  4♠ N      ♥5  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 7-Wolf-Collins
         50    1.00   2.00  4♠ S -1   ♥Q  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
         50    1.00   2.00  4♠ N -1   ♥Q  5-Collins-Hurley vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
         50    1.00   2.00  4♠ N -1   ♥4  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 4-Swift-Schottle
2 ♠AT4
♥953
♦975
♣T982
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠K97
♥8
♦QJ843
♣KQ75
♠QJ8652
♥AK6
♦2
♣AJ4
♠3
♥QJT742
♦AKT6
♣63
4
1115
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥  ♣3 ♦4 ♠2 NT3
EW: 3♣ 3♦ 5♠ 4NT  ♥6
LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: -450 5♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        420    3.00   0.00  4♠ E      ♥2  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 7-Wolf-Collins
        450    1.00   2.00  4♠ E +1   ♦A  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 4-Swift-Schottle
        450    1.00   2.00  4♠ E +1   ♦A  5-Collins-Hurley vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        450    1.00   2.00  4♠ E +1   ♦A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
3 ♠AK98732
♥KJ9
♦-
♣643
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠QJ
♥QT
♦AKJT753
♣K2
♠5
♥A85
♦Q842
♣JT985
♠T64
♥76432
♦96
♣AQ7
11
167
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♥ 5♠  ♣5 ♦2 NT5
EW: 1♣ 4/5♦  ♥3/4 ♠1/2 NT5
LoTT: 22 - 21 = +1
Par: +200 6♦*-E-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          3.00   0.00  4♠ N +1   ♦2  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 7-Wolf-Collins
  420          2.00   1.00  4♠ N      ♣J  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
  170          1.00   2.00  3♠ N +1   ♦2  5-Collins-Hurley vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        100    0.00   3.00  5♠* N -1  ♦Q  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 4-Swift-Schottle
4 ♠AK62
♥T87
♦87
♣KJ93
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠Q
♥AQJ92
♦JT9653
♣6
♠T93
♥643
♦AK4
♣AT85
♠J8754
♥K5
♦Q2
♣Q742
11
1011
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 1♠  ♦1 ♥1 NT1
EW: 6♦ 6♥ 2NT  ♣6 ♠6
LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: -1400 6♠*-NS/6♣*-NS-5
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
    PASS       3.00   0.00  Pass Out      6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 7-Wolf-Collins
        200    2.00   1.00  3♥ W +2   ♦8  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 5-Collins-Hurley
        680    0.50   2.50  4♥ W +2   ♠A  4-Swift-Schottle vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
        680    0.50   2.50  4♥ W +2   ♠A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
5 ♠T832
♥KQ
♦J96
♣QT42
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠Q7
♥963
♦QT87432
♣K
♠965
♥T842
♦AK
♣J653
♠AKJ4
♥AJ75
♦5
♣A987
8
78
17
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5♣ 1♦ 4♥ 5♠ 4NT
EW:  ♣2 ♦6 ♥2 ♠1 NT2
LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +650 5♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  300          3.00   0.00  3♦* W -2  ♠5  4-Swift-Schottle vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
  170          1.00   2.00  3♠ N +1   ♦K  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 5-Collins-Hurley
  170          1.00   2.00  3♠ N +1   ♦K  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 7-Wolf-Collins
  170          1.00   2.00  2♠ N +2   ♦A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
6 ♠J2
♥JT87
♦T42
♣A743
Dlr: East
Vul: E-W
♠A74
♥AK53
♦9763
♣K8
♠T3
♥942
♦KJ5
♣QJT95
♠KQ9865
♥Q6
♦AQ8
♣62
6
147
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥ 2♠ 2NT  ♣6 ♦6
EW: 1♣ 1♦  ♥6 ♠4 NT5
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: +120 2NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  170          3.00   0.00  2♠ S +2   ♥5  4-Swift-Schottle vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
  140          2.00   1.00  2♠ S +1   ♣8  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 7-Wolf-Collins
  110          1.00   2.00  2♠ S      ♥A  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 5-Collins-Hurley
        100    0.00   3.00  3♠ S -2   ♥A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
7 ♠T854
♥AJT
♦743
♣942
Dlr: South
Vul: Both
♠KQ976
♥Q9743
♦Q9
♣7
♠A
♥K86
♦AJT2
♣AKT53
♠J32
♥52
♦K865
♣QJ86
5
919
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣4 ♦3/2 ♥2 ♠3 NT4
EW: 3♣ 4/3♦ 5♥ 4♠ 3NT
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: -650 5♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  6♥ W -1   ♦3  7-Wolf-Collins vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
        600    1.50   1.50  3N E      ♥9  4-Swift-Schottle vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        600    1.50   1.50  3N E      ♦5  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        630    0.00   3.00  3N E +1   ♣8  5-Collins-Hurley vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
8 ♠AKQ2
♥-
♦AKQT53
♣T92
Dlr: West
Vul: None
♠J74
♥QT42
♦4
♣AKQ75
♠963
♥AJ7653
♦7
♣843
♠T85
♥K98
♦J9862
♣J6
18
125
5
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5♦ 4♠ 1NT  ♣5 ♥5
EW: 1♣ 2♥  ♦1 ♠3 NT3
LoTT: 19 - 21 = -2
Par: +420 4♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          3.00   0.00  5♦* N +1  ♥A  7-Wolf-Collins vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
  420          1.50   1.50  5♦ N +1   ♥A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
  420          1.50   1.50  5♦ N +1   ♥7  5-Collins-Hurley vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
  150          0.00   3.00  5♥ E -3   ♦8  4-Swift-Schottle vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
9 ♠842
♥85
♦J76
♣KQT64
Dlr: North
Vul: E-W
♠AKJ
♥KT73
♦T82
♣J95
♠T65
♥AQ642
♦A94
♣82
♠Q973
♥J9
♦KQ53
♣A73
6
1210
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 1♦  ♥4 ♠6 NT4
EW: 3♥ 1♠ 2NT  ♣6 ♦6
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -140 3♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  4♥ W -1   ♠3  7-Wolf-Collins vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
        140    1.50   1.50  3♥ W      ♣A  5-Collins-Hurley vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
        140    1.50   1.50  2♥ E +1   ♦K  4-Swift-Schottle vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        170    0.00   3.00  3♥ W +1   ♣A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
10 ♠JT92
♥K74
♦A96
♣JT6
Dlr: East
Vul: Both
♠65
♥A93
♦T83
♣AQ952
♠K83
♥Q65
♦KJ72
♣K83
♠AQ74
♥JT82
♦Q54
♣74
9
1012
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥ 2♠  ♣5 ♦6 NT6
EW: 2♣ 1♦ 1NT  ♥6 ♠5
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +110 2♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          3.00   0.00  2♣ E -2   ♠J  5-Collins-Hurley vs 7-Wolf-Collins
  100          2.00   1.00  3♣ E -1   ♠J  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
         90    1.00   2.00  2♣ E      ♠J  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
        110    0.00   3.00  3♣ E      ♠J  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 4-Swift-Schottle
11 ♠95
♥AJ7
♦AKT97
♣J72
Dlr: South
Vul: None
♠AKJ863
♥KQ4
♦J53
♣5
♠T4
♥T5
♦642
♣AKQT93
♠Q72
♥98632
♦Q8
♣864
13
149
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♦  ♣1 ♥6 ♠1/2 NT1
EW: 3♣ 3♠ 1NT  ♦6 ♥5
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -140 3♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  4♠ E -1   ♦A  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        110    2.00   1.00  3♣ E      ♦Q  5-Collins-Hurley vs 7-Wolf-Collins
        140    1.00   2.00  3♠ E      ♦A  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
        800    0.00   3.00  4♥* N -4  ♠A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 4-Swift-Schottle
12 ♠K84
♥K52
♦K864
♣KT7
Dlr: West
Vul: N-S
♠AJT2
♥QJ84
♦93
♣862
♠95
♥AT3
♦T75
♣AJ543
♠Q763
♥976
♦AQJ2
♣Q9
12
89
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♦ 1NT  ♣5 ♥5 ♠6
EW: 2/1♣ 2♥ 1♠  ♦6/5 NT6
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -110 2♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  120          3.00   0.00  2N N      ♣4  5-Collins-Hurley vs 7-Wolf-Collins
   90          2.00   1.00  2♦ S      ♦9  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
        100    0.50   2.50  2N N -1   ♣4  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        100    0.50   2.50  2♠ S -1   ♣6  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 4-Swift-Schottle
13 ♠QJ2
♥65
♦AKJ4
♣AT52
Dlr: North
Vul: Both
♠AK87
♥T932
♦965
♣76
♠T43
♥Q87
♦Q873
♣K93
♠965
♥AKJ4
♦T2
♣QJ84
15
77
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♣ 2♦ 2♥ 2♠ 3NT
EW:  ♣3 ♦5/4 ♥4 ♠4 NT4
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: +600 3NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  630          2.50   0.50  3N N +1   ♦3  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
  630          2.50   0.50  3N N +1   ♦3  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 5-Collins-Hurley
  130          1.00   2.00  3♣ N +1   ♦3  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        200    0.00   3.00  4♥ N -2   ♠T  7-Wolf-Collins vs 4-Swift-Schottle
14 ♠-
♥QJ975
♦AQJ7
♣KQ84
Dlr: East
Vul: None
♠A853
♥AT8
♦K53
♣932
♠KQT42
♥6
♦T94
♣AJ65
♠J976
♥K432
♦862
♣T7
15
1110
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦ 4/3♥ 1/-NT
       ♣6 ♠5/4 NT7/6
EW: -/1♣ 2♠
       ♣6/7 ♦5 ♥2/3 NT5/6
LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: +300 4♠*-EW-2
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          2.50   0.50  5♥ S      ♠K  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
  450          2.50   0.50  4♥ S +1   ♠K  7-Wolf-Collins vs 4-Swift-Schottle
   50          0.50   2.50  4♠ W -1   ♥2  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
   50          0.50   2.50  3♠ W -1   ♥K  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 5-Collins-Hurley
15 ♠Q4
♥J97643
♦62
♣T98
Dlr: South
Vul: N-S
♠T75
♥KQT52
♦K7
♣J43
♠K82
♥A
♦AQJ84
♣K765
♠AJ963
♥8
♦T953
♣AQ2
3
917
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♠  ♣4 ♦4 ♥6 NT4
EW: 2♣ 2♦ 2NT  ♥6 ♠6
LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: -120 2NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  500          3.00   0.00  4♥* W -3  ♠Q  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 5-Collins-Hurley
   50          2.00   1.00  2N E -1   ♠6  6-Dusharme-Dusharme vs 1-Hunter-Lagodimos
        130    1.00   2.00  3♦ E +1   ♥8  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        150    0.00   3.00  2N E +1   ♦T  7-Wolf-Collins vs 4-Swift-Schottle
16 ♠T543
♥AK76
♦876
♣K7
Dlr: West
Vul: E-W
♠2
♥QJ5
♦T5432
♣AQ86
♠AQJ
♥9843
♦A9
♣J953
♠K9876
♥T2
♦KQJ
♣T42
10
912
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♠  ♣4 ♦5 ♥5 NT6
EW: 2♣ 1/2♦ 1♥  ♠4 NT6
LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +140 3♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          3.00   0.00  4♣ E -2   ♠6  7-Wolf-Collins vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
  140          1.50   1.50  3♠ S      ♦5  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 5-Collins-Hurley
  140          1.50   1.50  2♠ S +1   ♥Q  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
         50    0.00   3.00  4♠ S -1   ♣8  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 4-Swift-Schottle
17 ♠KQT2
♥Q9
♦52
♣J9543
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠A7
♥AT84
♦J943
♣A62
♠9853
♥J632
♦K
♣KQT8
♠J64
♥K75
♦AQT876
♣7
8
139
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦  ♣5 ♥4 ♠6 NT5
EW: 1♣ 3♥ 1♠ 1NT  ♦5
LoTT: 17 - 16 = +1
Par: -140 3♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   90          3.00   0.00  2♦ S      ♠A  7-Wolf-Collins vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
   50          2.00   1.00  2♥ W -1       3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 4-Swift-Schottle
        110    1.00   2.00  2♥ E      ♣7  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 5-Collins-Hurley
        140    0.00   3.00  2♥ E +1   ♣7  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
18 ♠7
♥KJ9543
♦JT
♣Q976
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠KQ2
♥AQT
♦865
♣KJ52
♠9854
♥8
♦KQ97
♣AT84
♠AJT63
♥762
♦A432
♣3
7
159
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥  ♣4/3 ♦4 ♠4 NT3
EW: 3♣ 2♦ 3♠ 3/4NT  ♥4
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -430 4NT-E
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  300          3.00   0.00  3♠* W -2  ♠7  3-Kitamura-Kitamura vs 4-Swift-Schottle
        180    2.00   1.00  2N W +2   ♥5  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        400    0.50   2.50  3N W      ♥5  7-Wolf-Collins vs 2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni
        400    0.50   2.50  3♥** N -1 ♦K  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 5-Collins-Hurley
19 ♠765
♥964
♦764
♣A964
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠QJT82
♥AQ
♦AKT2
♣75
♠K9
♥J8753
♦Q83
♣KQJ
♠A43
♥KT2
♦J95
♣T832
4
1612
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣3/4 ♦2 ♥3 ♠2 NT2
EW: 3♣ 5♦ 4♥ 5♠ 4NT
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: -650 5♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        620    3.00   0.00  4♥ E      ♦8  4-Swift-Schottle vs 5-Collins-Hurley
        650    2.00   1.00  4♠ W +1   ♥4  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        660    0.50   2.50  3N E +2   ♣2  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        660    0.50   2.50  3N E +2   ♣2  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 7-Wolf-Collins
20 ♠A976
♥863
♦K
♣AK743
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠K853
♥A754
♦AT6
♣Q5
♠J42
♥KJT
♦QJ8532
♣J
♠QT
♥Q92
♦974
♣T9862
14
139
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣  ♦2 ♥3 ♠5 NT3
EW: 4♦ 4♥ 2♠ 1NT  ♣5
LoTT: 18 - 19 = -1
Par: -620 4♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          3.00   0.00  3♦ E -2   ♠Q  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        110    1.50   1.50  3♦ W      ♣A  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        110    1.50   1.50  3♦ W      ♣A  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 7-Wolf-Collins
        670    0.00   3.00  3♦* W     ♣7  4-Swift-Schottle vs 5-Collins-Hurley
21 ♠KQ43
♥QJ82
♦T
♣JT86
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠A7652
♥K
♦AKQ965
♣K
♠J
♥AT9753
♦32
♣AQ52
♠T98
♥64
♦J874
♣9743
9
1911
1
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣4 ♦0 ♥2 ♠3 NT2
EW: 3♣ 6♦ 5♥ 4♠ 5NT
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -920 6♦-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  6♥ E -2   ♠T  2-Piazzoni-Piazzoni vs 6-Dusharme-Dusharme
        140    2.00   1.00  2♠ W +1   ♦T  8-Cogdill-Crail vs 7-Wolf-Collins
        400    1.00   2.00  3N E      ♠T  1-Hunter-Lagodimos vs 3-Kitamura-Kitamura
        420    0.00   3.00  5♦ W +1   ♠K  4-Swift-Schottle vs 5-Collins-Hurley