Dec 9, 2015 Game Result

? Explanation of report features View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

Field strength: Mean: 399 MP Geomean: 93 MP
(based on 15 players, 1 non ACBL player ignored)

★ ★ ★ Masterpoint Winners ★ ★ ★
Partnership	Pct	Rank	MP
Dave Cleary - Roy Shepard	58.73	1st A	1.69
James Ciolli - Manu Chaganlal	55.56	2nd A	1.18
Bill Osgood - Kenneth Gestiehr	54.76	3rd A	0.85

EVENT>Wednesday Evening Pairs  |SESSION>Wednesday Eve|SECTION> E
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>December 9, 2015   |SANCTION>ST1512002 | 12/09/2015 21:50
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> KATHIE ANGIONE  |RATING>STAC, CLUB>260323            |MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   31.5 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>None/2000/750  |CLUB>EASTLAKE BRIDGE CLUB
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=7/C=7                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Kenneth Gestiehr       Bill Osgood              C    3     3     3     34.50  54.76  0.85(A) 
 2 Anisuz Zaman           Hideki Kitamura          C    .     .     .     28.50  45.24          
 3 Fran Hunter            Doral Hunter             C    .     .     .     31.00  49.21          
 4 Kathie Angione         John Peter Lagodimos     A    NE    .     .     42.50  67.46          
 5 Manu Chaganlal         James Ciolli             C    2     2     2     35.00  55.56  1.18(A) 
 6 Cheryl Rankin          Carol Adair              C    .     .     .     25.00  39.68          
 7 Dave Cleary            Roy Shepard              C    1     1     1     37.00  58.73  1.69(A) 
 8 Elisabeth Cogdill      Charlotte Bockman        C    .     .     .     18.50  29.37          
                                          Totals                         252.00

♠A
♥AT9765
♦95
♣KQ87

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠KJ987
♥K84
♦A84
♣T3

♠QT65
♥Q3
♦T73
♣AJ94

♠432
♥J2
♦KQJ62
♣652

	13
11		9
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♦ 2♥ ♣6 ♠4 NT5/4

EW: 3♠ 1NT ♣6 ♦6 ♥5

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: -140 3♠-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  110          3.00   0.00  2♥ N      ♠T  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Rankin-Adair
        100    2.00   1.00  4♥ N -2   ♠5  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
        140    1.00   2.00  3♠ W      ♥7  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
        170    0.00   3.00  3♠ E +1   ♥2  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood

♠985
♥T86
♦87
♣AT654

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠QJ3
♥J3
♦KQJ52
♣K32

♠AT7
♥A942
♦T643
♣Q8

♠K642
♥KQ75
♦A9
♣J97

	4
13		10
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ ♦4 ♥6 ♠6 NT6

EW: 3♦ 1/-♠ 1NT ♣5 ♥6 ♠7/6

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: -110 3♦-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  2♥ E -1   ♣J  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Rankin-Adair
        110    1.50   1.50  3♦ W      ♣A  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
        110    1.50   1.50  2♦ W +1   ♣A  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
        150    0.00   3.00  1N E +2   ♦A  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood

♠6
♥AT84
♦AT32
♣KJT3

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠KJ975
♥976
♦QJ6
♣85

♠AQT2
♥QJ32
♦85
♣A42

♠843
♥K5
♦K974
♣Q976

	12
7		13
	8

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 4♦ 1♥ 1NT ♠5

EW: 1♠ ♣3 ♦3 ♥6 NT6

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +130 4♦-NS/4♣-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  300          3.00   0.00  3♥ E -3   ♣6  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  110          2.00   1.00  3♦ S      ♠5  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
  100          1.00   2.00  2♠ W -1   ♣J  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
        110    0.00   3.00  2♠ W      ♦A  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos

♠AQT976
♥Q6
♦T4
♣T72

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠KJ4
♥J9854
♦9653
♣8

♠3
♥AK
♦AKQJ72
♣AKQ9

♠852
♥T732
♦8
♣J6543

	8
5		26
	1

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣3 ♦0 ♥2 ♠6 NT1

EW: 3/4♣ 6♦ 4/5♥ -/1♠ 5/6NT
♠6/7

LoTT: 18 - 19 = -1
Par: -1440 6NT-W

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        680    3.00   0.00  4♥ W +2   ♠A  6-Rankin-Adair vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
       1370    1.00   2.00  6♦ E      ♠6  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
       1370    1.00   2.00  6♦ E      ♠2  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
       1370    1.00   2.00  6♦ E      ♠2  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura

♠6
♥T642
♦AJ632
♣Q96

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠2
♥9875
♦84
♣KJT854

♠AJT9873
♥AK3
♦Q5
♣2

♠KQ54
♥QJ
♦KT97
♣A73

	7
4		14
	15

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♦ 1♥ 3NT ♣5 ♠6

EW: 1♣ 1♠ ♦3 ♥5 NT4

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +500 4♠*-EW/4♣*-EW-3

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.50   0.50  4♠ E -2   ♣A  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  100          2.50   0.50  3♠* E -1  ♥Q  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
        140    1.00   2.00  2♠ E +1   ♦7  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        200    0.00   3.00  5♦* N -1  ♥A  6-Rankin-Adair vs 7-Cleary-Shepard

♠AKQJ4
♥86
♦-
♣AK8742

Dlr: East
Vul: E-W

♠T87
♥AQT4
♦KJT7
♣T6

♠532
♥-
♦986432
♣J953

♠96
♥KJ97532
♦AQ5
♣Q

	17
10		1
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 5♣ 4♥ 6/5♠ 4NT ♦6

EW: 1♦ ♣2 ♥3 ♠1 NT3

LoTT: 17 - 19 = -2
Par: +980 6♠-N

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          3.00   0.00  5♠ N      ♦9  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  430          2.00   1.00  3N N +1   ♦9  6-Rankin-Adair vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
         50    1.00   2.00  4♥ S -1   ♦7  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    0.00   3.00  6♥ S -2   ♠7  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood

♠AQ6
♥AJ3
♦AJ4
♣J874

Dlr: South
Vul: Both

♠K5
♥KQ62
♦965
♣KT93

♠742
♥875
♦KQT73
♣65

♠JT983
♥T94
♦82
♣AQ2

	17
11		5
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 1♦ 2♥ 4♠ 4/3NT

EW: ♣4 ♦6 ♥4/5 ♠3 NT3

LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +630 4NT-N

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          3.00   0.00  4♠ S      ♣T  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  200          2.00   1.00  2♠ N +3   ♣6  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
  170          1.00   2.00  2♠ N +2   ♦K  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
  140          0.00   3.00  3♠ S      ♥2  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 3-Hunter-Hunter

♠AK8
♥T743
♦K9832
♣5

Dlr: West
Vul: None

♠QT432
♥Q2
♦J7
♣A976

♠976
♥AKJ85
♦T5
♣QT4

♠J5
♥96
♦AQ64
♣KJ832

	10
9		10
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 4♦ 1NT ♥6 ♠6

EW: 1♥ 1♠ ♣5 ♦3 NT6

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +130 4♦-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  500          3.00   0.00  3♠* W -3  ♣5  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  130          2.00   1.00  2♦ N +2   ♥K  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        110    1.00   2.00  2♥ E      ♦4  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
        140    0.00   3.00  2♥ E +1   ♣3  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood

♠KQ75
♥K7
♦QT4
♣A953

Dlr: North
Vul: E-W

♠A2
♥T83
♦A8762
♣T86

♠J963
♥Q62
♦K9
♣KQJ2

♠T84
♥AJ954
♦J53
♣74

	14
8		12
	6

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♥ 1♠ 1NT ♣6 ♦6

EW: 1♣ 1♦ ♥4 ♠5/6 NT5

LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: +110 2♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  300          3.00   0.00  2N E -3       4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  200          2.00   1.00  2N E -2   ♣4  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
  120          1.00   2.00  1N S +1   ♦6  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
  110          0.00   3.00  1♠ N +1   ♣K  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura

♠AQ94
♥AKQ9532
♦-
♣Q8

Dlr: East
Vul: Both

♠T3
♥T64
♦-
♣AKT97652

♠K75
♥J7
♦JT8742
♣J4

♠J862
♥8
♦AKQ9653
♣3

	17
7		6
	10

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♦ 4♥ 5♠ ♣4 NT5

EW: 3♣ ♦3 ♥2 ♠1 NT2/5

LoTT: 20 - 18 = +2
Par: +650 5♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  680          3.00   0.00  4♥ N +2   ♣J  6-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
  650          2.00   1.00  4♥ N +1   ♣J  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
  500          1.00   2.00  1♣* W -2  ♥A  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
  230          0.00   3.00  3♥ N +3   ♣J  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos

♠Q85
♥JT32
♦Q4
♣AK74

Dlr: South
Vul: None

♠AJT97
♥AQ97
♦T5
♣62

♠K6
♥8
♦AK9876
♣T953

♠432
♥K654
♦J32
♣QJ8

	12
11		10
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦3/2 ♥5 ♠3 NT5/4

EW: 2♣ 3♦ 1/2♥ 4♠ 2NT

LoTT: 14 - 16 = -2
Par: -420 4♠-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  4♠ W -1   ♣A  6-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
        100    2.00   1.00  2♥ S -2   ♦T  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
        150    1.00   2.00  1N E +2   ♥4  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        170    0.00   3.00  2♠ W +2   ♣A  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos

♠84
♥J7
♦QJ983
♣8764

Dlr: West
Vul: N-S

♠QJ63
♥T983
♦AK
♣AQ9

♠KT752
♥Q542
♦54
♣KT

♠A9
♥AK6
♦T762
♣J532

	4
16		8
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♣ 1♦ ♥3 ♠4 NT4

EW: 4♥ 3♠ 3NT ♣6 ♦6

LoTT: 16 - 18 = -2
Par: -420 4♥-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  4♠ W -1   ♦Q  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        420    1.00   2.00  4♥ W      ♠8  6-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
        420    1.00   2.00  4♥ W      ♦J  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
        420    1.00   2.00  4♥ W      ♦2  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos

♠T
♥J9875
♦AQ4
♣KQ87

Dlr: North
Vul: Both

♠AK954
♥T6
♦JT
♣J942

♠J2
♥AKQ
♦K873
♣AT63

♠Q8763
♥432
♦9652
♣5

	12
9		17
	2

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣3 ♦4/3 ♥4 ♠3 NT3

EW: 4♣ 2♦ 2♥ 3♠ 4NT

LoTT: 14 - 16 = -2
Par: -630 4NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        110    3.00   0.00  2♠ E      ♥2  6-Rankin-Adair vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
        630    1.50   1.50  3N E +1   ♠3  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        630    1.50   1.50  3N E +1   ♥2  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
        660    0.00   3.00  3N E +2   ♥3  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Hunter-Hunter

♠T743
♥AT
♦AKJT73
♣A

Dlr: East
Vul: None

♠82
♥532
♦8542
♣JT74

♠AKQJ6
♥Q8
♦6
♣K9632

♠95
♥KJ9764
♦Q9
♣Q85

	16
1		15
	8

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 5♦ 5♥ 1♠ 2NT ♣5

EW: 2♣ ♦0 ♥0 ♠5 NT0

LoTT: 19 - 17 = +2
Par: +450 5♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          3.00   0.00  4♥ S +1   ♠8  6-Rankin-Adair vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood
  150          2.00   1.00  3♦ N +2   ♠2  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
  130          1.00   2.00  3♦ N +1   ♠A  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
  100          0.00   3.00  4♣ E -2   ♦9  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠KQJ2
♥532
♦QJ63
♣AK

Dlr: South
Vul: N-S

♠A853
♥AKQ6
♦K8
♣865

♠T96
♥J98
♦T954
♣QJ9

♠74
♥T74
♦A72
♣T7432

	16
16		4
	4

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♦ ♣6 ♥6 ♠6 NT6

EW: 1♥ 1♠ ♣6 ♦5 NT6

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: -80 1♠-EW/1♥-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         70    3.00   0.00  1♣ W      ♣A  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
         90    2.00   1.00  1N W      ♠K  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
        100    1.00   2.00  2♦ N -1   ♠T  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        200    0.00   3.00  2♠ N -2   ♥9  6-Rankin-Adair vs 1-Gestiehr-Osgood

♠T2
♥AK64
♦K65
♣AQ64

Dlr: West
Vul: E-W

♠AKJ964
♥2
♦A987
♣T2

♠Q
♥J973
♦Q32
♣KJ873

♠8753
♥QT85
♦JT4
♣95

	16
12		9
	3

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♥ ♣4 ♦4 ♠3 NT5

EW: 2♣ 3♦ 4♠ 1NT ♥5

LoTT: 17 - 15 = +2
Par: -620 4♠-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        110    2.50   0.50  2♠ W      ♥A  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        110    2.50   0.50  2♠ W      ♥A  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 6-Rankin-Adair
        300    1.00   2.00  3♥* S -2  ♠A  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        500    0.00   3.00  3♥* N -3  ♠Q  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos

♠AT6
♥A62
♦AQT8
♣832

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠K32
♥T8
♦J654
♣AQ64

♠J754
♥J5
♦K92
♣KJT9

♠Q98
♥KQ9743
♦73
♣75

	14
10		9
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♦ 4♥ 1♠ 2NT ♣6

EW: 1♣ ♦6 ♥3 ♠6 NT5

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +420 4♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  170          3.00   0.00  2♥ S +2   ♠3  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
  150          2.00   1.00  1N N +2   ♣T  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
  140          1.00   2.00  2♥ S +1   ♣6  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 6-Rankin-Adair
   90          0.00   3.00  1♦ N +1   ♥J  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠T5432
♥-
♦AJ842
♣Q73

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠QJ6
♥Q54
♦K965
♣J86

♠7
♥AJT9732
♦-
♣AT952

♠AK98
♥K86
♦QT73
♣K4

	7
9		9
	15

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♦ 5/4♠ 2NT ♣4 ♥3

EW: 1♣ 4♥ ♦2 ♠2 NT3

LoTT: 21 - 19 = +2
Par: +300 6♥*-EW-2

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          3.00   0.00  4♠ S      ♥4  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  100          2.00   1.00  5♥ E -2   ♠A  7-Cleary-Shepard vs 2-Zaman-Kitamura
        200    1.00   2.00  3♠ E +2   ♠8  3-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Angione-Lagodimos
        420    0.00   3.00  4♥ E      ♠K  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠QJT5
♥QJ96
♦T932
♣3

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠K76
♥AK85
♦J74
♣J76

♠A93
♥73
♦KQ8
♣KT984

♠842
♥T42
♦A65
♣AQ52

	6
12		12
	10

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦6 ♥6 ♠6 NT4

EW: 3♣ 1♦ 1♥ 1♠ 2NT

LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: -120 2NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  3N E -1   ♥2  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        110    2.00   1.00  2♣ E +1   ♦6  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
        600    0.50   2.50  3N E      ♣2  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 6-Rankin-Adair
        600    0.50   2.50  3N E      ♣2  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 7-Cleary-Shepard

♠QT2
♥AK75
♦94
♣KQT5

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠AK96543
♥Q96
♦Q
♣87

♠J7
♥J4
♦KT762
♣J962

♠8
♥T832
♦AJ853
♣A43

	14
11		6
	9

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 3♦ 4♥ 1NT ♠6

EW: 1♠ ♣4 ♦4 ♥3 NT5

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +620 4♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  3♠ W -1   ♥A  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 3-Hunter-Hunter
        100    1.50   1.50  4♥ S -1   ♠A  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 6-Rankin-Adair
        100    1.50   1.50  4♥ S -1   ♠A  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        110    0.00   3.00  2♠ W      ♦9  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 7-Cleary-Shepard

♠Q54
♥KQT2
♦AK
♣AQT9

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠JT98732
♥-
♦JT963
♣4

♠6
♥AJ9843
♦54
♣KJ63

♠AK
♥765
♦Q872
♣8752

	20
2		9
	9

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 2♦ 2♥ -/1♠ 4/3NT
♠6/7

EW: ♣4 ♦4 ♥5 ♠6 NT3

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: +630 4NT-N

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  630          2.50   0.50  3N N +1   ♠T  2-Zaman-Kitamura vs 6-Rankin-Adair
  630          2.50   0.50  3N N +1   ♥9  4-Angione-Lagodimos vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  500          1.00   2.00  4♠* W -3  ♦A  8-Cogdill-Bockman vs 7-Cleary-Shepard
        100    0.00   3.00  3N N -1   ♥8  1-Gestiehr-Osgood vs 3-Hunter-Hunter