Apr 13, 2016 Game Result

? Explanation of report features View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

Field strength: Mean: 427 MP Geomean: 113 MP
(based on 16 players)

★ ★ ★ Masterpoint Winners ★ ★ ★
Partnership	Pct	Rank	MP
James Ciolli - Manu Chaganlal	67.46	1st A	0.80
Anisuz Zaman - Hideki Kitamura	61.11	2nd A	0.56
Hiroko Kitamura - Judi Bunch	50.00	3rd A	0.40
Cheryl Rankin - Elisabeth Cogdill	46.03	2nd B	0.25

EVENT>Wednesday Evening Pairs  |SESSION>Wednesday Eve|SECTION> E
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>April 13, 2016     |CLUB NO.>260323    | 04/13/2016 21:46
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> John Lagodimos  |RATING>Club Masterpoint (100%, 70% Open)|MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   31.5 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>None/200       |CLUB>Eastlake Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=5                           ,---,-------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |      Section      |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Bockman Charlotte      Kenneth Gestiehr         B    .     .     20.50  32.54          
 2 Judi Bunch             Hiroko Kitamura          A    3     .     31.50  50.00  0.40(A) 
 3 Roy Shepard            Thomas Turner            B    .     .     24.00  38.10          
 4 Bill Osgood            Dave Cleary              B    .     .     28.00  44.44          
 5 Manu Chaganlal         James Ciolli             A    1     .     42.50  67.46  0.80(A) 
 6 John Peter Lagodimos   Kathie Angione           A    NE    .     38.00  60.32          
 7 Anisuz Zaman           Hideki Kitamura          B    2     1     38.50  61.11  0.56(A) 
 8 Cheryl Rankin          Elisabeth Cogdill        B    .     2     29.00  46.03  0.25(B) 
                                          Totals                   252.00

♠AJ87
♥AKQ84
♦876
♣K

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠Q2
♥J32
♦A
♣QT98732

♠T9643
♥76
♦JT3
♣J65

♠K5
♥T95
♦KQ9542
♣A4

	17
9		2
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 6♦ 6♥ 4♠ 6NT ♣6

EW: 1♣ ♦1 ♥1 ♠3 NT1

LoTT: 19 - 19 = 0
Par: +990 6NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  480          2.50   0.50  5♥ N +1   ♣5  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
  480          2.50   0.50  4♥ N +2   ♣J  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  450          0.50   2.50  4♥ S +1   ♣8  3-Shepard-Turner vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  450          0.50   2.50  4♥ N +1   ♠4  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr

♠Q963
♥9732
♦K93
♣76

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠K7
♥QJ6
♦AQJT862
♣8

♠AJT8
♥AK
♦-
♣AKQJ432

♠542
♥T854
♦754
♣T95

	5
13		22
	0

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣0 ♦1 ♥2 ♠1 NT0

EW: 7♣ 6♦ 4♥ 6♠ 7NT

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -1520 7NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  6N E -1   ♣T  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
        940    2.00   1.00  6♣ E +1   ♣T  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
       1020    0.50   2.50  6N E +1   ♥4  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
       1020    0.50   2.50  6N E +1   ♣9  3-Shepard-Turner vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura

♠A9
♥QJ742
♦4
♣A6542

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠KQ86
♥653
♦AT962
♣T

♠J75
♥AT
♦Q8753
♣K73

♠T432
♥K98
♦KJ
♣QJ98

	11
9		10
	10

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 3/2♥ 1NT ♦3 ♠5

EW: 3♦ 1♠ ♣4 ♥4 NT6

LoTT: 18 - 19 = -1
Par: +140 3♥-N

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          3.00   0.00  4♥ N      ♦5  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  130          2.00   1.00  3♣ N +1   ♦5  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
         50    1.00   2.00  3♥ N -1   ♦5  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        110    0.00   3.00  3♦ E      ♥K  3-Shepard-Turner vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura

♠AT762
♥J9873
♦-
♣KT5

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠K84
♥T2
♦Q74
♣97632

♠95
♥K654
♦AKT82
♣J4

♠QJ3
♥AQ
♦J9653
♣AQ8

	8
5		11
	16

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 2♦ 5♥ 6♠ 4NT

EW: ♣3/4 ♦5 ♥1 ♠1 NT3

LoTT: 17 - 16 = +1
Par: +1430 6♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  680          2.50   0.50  4♠ S +2   ♥T  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
  680          2.50   0.50  4♠ N +2   ♦A  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        300    1.00   2.00  3N S -3   ♦4  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
        600    0.00   3.00  3N W          3-Shepard-Turner vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠Q43
♥AKQ84
♦QJ942
♣-

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠KJ65
♥973
♦T763
♣52

♠A82
♥J652
♦AK
♣K763

♠T97
♥T
♦85
♣AQJT984

	14
4		15
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 2♦ 2/1♥ 1♠ 1NT

EW: ♣4 ♦5 ♥5 ♠6 NT6

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: +110 2♥-N

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  150          3.00   0.00  3♠ E -3   ♥A  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    2.00   1.00  4♣ S -1   ♠5  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
        200    1.00   2.00  4♣ S -2   ♦6  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        800    0.00   3.00  4♥* S -3  ♠A  3-Shepard-Turner vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠KT9842
♥7
♦KQT
♣T94

Dlr: East
Vul: E-W

♠76
♥K42
♦A9532
♣Q82

♠A53
♥QT865
♦7
♣KJ73

♠QJ
♥AJ93
♦J864
♣A65

	8
9		10
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♠ 1NT ♣6 ♦6 ♥4

EW: 1♣ 3♥ ♦6 ♠4 NT5

LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -140 3♥-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  140          3.00   0.00  3♠ N      ♦7  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  110          2.00   1.00  2♠ S      ♦7  3-Shepard-Turner vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        100    1.00   2.00  2♦ S -2   ♠7  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
        670    0.00   3.00  2♥* E     ♠Q  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura

♠K82
♥T3
♦J765
♣K953

Dlr: South
Vul: Both

♠QT53
♥KQJ874
♦2
♣87

♠AJ96
♥A6
♦AT94
♣AQ4

♠74
♥952
♦KQ83
♣JT62

	7
8		19
	6

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦4 ♥0 ♠0 NT0

EW: 2♣ 2♦ 7♥ 7♠ 7NT

LoTT: 17 - 16 = +1
Par: -2220 7NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        710    1.50   1.50  4♠ E +3   ♦K  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        710    1.50   1.50  4♥ W +3   ♥T  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        710    1.50   1.50  4♥ W +3   ♥T  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
        710    1.50   1.50  4♥ W +3   ♣3  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 3-Shepard-Turner

♠K98
♥K8
♦QJ92
♣A865

Dlr: West
Vul: None

♠QJ2
♥96
♦AK8653
♣Q2

♠653
♥QJ743
♦T
♣JT74

♠AT74
♥AT52
♦74
♣K93

	13
12		4
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 2♦ 2♥ 3♠ 3NT

EW: ♣4 ♦5 ♥5 ♠4 NT4

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: +400 3NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1100          3.00   0.00  4♦* W -5  ♠K  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
  200          2.00   1.00  3♦ W -4   ♠8  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  100          1.00   2.00  1N W -2   ♠8  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
   50          0.00   3.00  2♦ W -1   ♣A  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 3-Shepard-Turner

♠5
♥KT62
♦KJ854
♣AT9

Dlr: North
Vul: E-W

♠98
♥AJ93
♦Q763
♣763

♠QT72
♥Q85
♦-
♣KJ8542

♠AKJ643
♥74
♦AT92
♣Q

	11
7		8
	14

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 6♦ 3/2♥ 5/4♠ 4NT ♣5

EW: 2♣ ♦1 ♥4 ♠2 NT2

LoTT: 20 - 18 = +2
Par: +920 6♦-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  460          3.00   0.00  3N N +2   ♥5  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
  440          2.00   1.00  5♦ N +2   ♣8  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
  420          1.00   2.00  4♠ S      ♣6  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  110          0.00   3.00  2♦ N +1   ♠2  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 3-Shepard-Turner

♠J873
♥A
♦AT9
♣KQ764

Dlr: East
Vul: Both

♠AQ94
♥K85
♦52
♣J532

♠6
♥QT9432
♦J873
♣T8

♠KT52
♥J76
♦KQ64
♣A9

	14
10		3
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 4♦ 4♠ 2NT ♥5/6

EW: 1♥ ♣3 ♦3 ♠2/3 NT4

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +620 4♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          2.50   0.50  4♠ S      ♥5  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  620          2.50   0.50  4♠ N      ♥T  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 3-Shepard-Turner
  600          1.00   2.00  3N S      ♠4  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        400    0.00   3.00  3N N -4   ♥T  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura

♠JT65
♥K73
♦AJ
♣QJ93

Dlr: South
Vul: None

♠Q943
♥AQ854
♦952
♣T

♠K7
♥J9
♦KT8763
♣654

♠A82
♥T62
♦Q4
♣AK872

	12
8		7
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 2♠ 2/1NT ♦4 ♥6/5

EW: 3♦ 1♥ ♣3 ♠5/4 NT4

LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: +100 4♦*-EW-1

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         50    2.50   0.50  3N S -1       6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 3-Shepard-Turner
         50    2.50   0.50  3N N -1   ♥J  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    1.00   2.00  3N N -2   ♦7  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
        150    0.00   3.00  1♠ N -3   ♥J  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura

♠9543
♥KT74
♦AK9
♣76

Dlr: West
Vul: N-S

♠T82
♥9
♦8642
♣AKT43

♠76
♥Q86532
♦J7
♣QJ5

♠AKQJ
♥AJ
♦QT53
♣982

	10
7		6
	17

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♣ 4♦ 2♥ 5♠ 2NT

EW: ♣5 ♦3 ♥5 ♠1 NT2

LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +650 5♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  680          3.00   0.00  4♠ S +2   ♣A  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 3-Shepard-Turner
  650          1.50   1.50  4♠ S +1   ♣A  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  650          1.50   1.50  4♠ N +1   ♥2  5-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    0.00   3.00  4♠ S -1   ♣K  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura

♠KQ52
♥JT72
♦863
♣A4

Dlr: North
Vul: Both

♠J43
♥Q953
♦AQ9
♣KQ3

♠T9
♥K6
♦J752
♣J9865

♠A876
♥A84
♦KT4
♣T72

	10
14		5
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♥ 3♠ ♣4 ♦6 NT6

EW: 3♣ 1♦ ♥5 ♠4 NT5

LoTT: 18 - 16 = +2
Par: +140 3♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  140          3.00   0.00  2♠ S +1   ♠3  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Shepard-Turner
  110          1.50   1.50  2♠ S          6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
  110          1.50   1.50  2♠ N      ♦T  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  100          0.00   3.00  2♣ W -1   ♥J  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠K8764
♥Q3
♦85
♣A853

Dlr: East
Vul: None

♠AJ32
♥8
♦K763
♣K972

♠9
♥9752
♦JT42
♣QJ64

♠QT5
♥AKJT64
♦AQ9
♣T

	9
11		4
	16

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 5♥ 5♠ 3NT ♣6 ♦6

EW: 1♣ 1♦ ♥1 ♠1 NT1

LoTT: 18 - 16 = +2
Par: +450 5♠-NS/5♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  480          3.00   0.00  4♥ S +2   ♥8  6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
  450          2.00   1.00  4♥ S +1   ♣2  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Shepard-Turner
  110          1.00   2.00  2♠ N      ♣Q  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
         50    0.00   3.00  4♠ N -1   ♣Q  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary

♠AT9
♥8
♦AQJT6542
♣6

Dlr: South
Vul: N-S

♠J73
♥KQJ74
♦K
♣A842

♠Q52
♥A9653
♦97
♣Q93

♠K864
♥T2
♦83
♣KJT75

	11
14		8
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♣ 5♦ 3♠ 1NT ♥5

EW: 2♥ ♣5 ♦2 ♠4 NT3

LoTT: 19 - 20 = -1
Par: +500 5♥*-EW-3

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  600          2.50   0.50  5♦ N      ♥A  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  600          2.50   0.50  5♦ N          6-Lagodimos-Angione vs 1-Charlotte-Gestiehr
  100          0.50   2.50  4♥ W -2   ♣6  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  100          0.50   2.50  3♥ W -2   ♣6  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Shepard-Turner

♠A95
♥AKJT8
♦J4
♣QJ3

Dlr: West
Vul: E-W

♠J4
♥64
♦QT3
♣AKT875

♠QT6
♥9752
♦8752
♣96

♠K8732
♥Q3
♦AK96
♣42

	16
10		2
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 4♦ 5♥ 4♠ 4NT

EW: ♣5 ♦3 ♥2 ♠1 NT3

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: +450 5♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          2.50   0.50  4♠ S      ♣9  3-Shepard-Turner vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
  420          2.50   0.50  4♥ N      ♣9  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  200          1.00   2.00  2♠ S +3   ♣A  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        100    0.00   3.00  5♥ N -2   ♣9  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠A42
♥AK2
♦K32
♣KT65

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠KQ985
♥876
♦Q65
♣Q4

♠J763
♥QT94
♦AJ
♣J83

♠T
♥J53
♦T9874
♣A972

	17
9		9
	5

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 3♦ 1♥ 1NT ♠5

EW: 2♠ ♣3 ♦3 ♥5/6 NT6

LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +130 4♣-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  180          3.00   0.00  1N N +3   ♥T  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
   90          2.00   1.00  1N S      ♥4  3-Shepard-Turner vs 4-Osgood-Cleary
        110    1.00   2.00  2♠ W      ♥K  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        150    0.00   3.00  3N N -3   ♥9  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione

♠7532
♥K
♦KJ
♣KT8654

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠K84
♥T95
♦T974
♣QJ2

♠Q6
♥AQJ7643
♦A63
♣7

♠AJT9
♥82
♦Q852
♣A93

	10
6		13
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 3♠ ♦6 ♥4 NT4

EW: 1♦ 3♥ 2NT ♣4 ♠4

LoTT: 18 - 19 = -1
Par: +100 3NT*-EW/4♥*-EW-1

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        140    3.00   0.00  2♥ E +1   ♦2  7-Zaman-Kitamura vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        200    2.00   1.00  3♥ E +2   ♠J  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        420    0.50   2.50  4♥ E      ♠J  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        420    0.50   2.50  4♥ E      ♣A  3-Shepard-Turner vs 4-Osgood-Cleary

♠JT972
♥QT
♦K9653
♣A

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠K8
♥KJ954
♦AQ
♣9873

♠AQ65
♥82
♦82
♣QJ642

♠43
♥A763
♦JT74
♣KT5

	10
13		9
	8

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♦ 1♠ ♣3 ♥5 NT5

EW: 3♣ 1/2♥ -/1NT
♦4 ♠5/6 NT6/7

LoTT: 17 - 18 = -1
Par: -100 3♦*-NS-1

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          3.00   0.00  3N E -2   ♦J  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
    PASS       2.00   1.00  Pass Out      1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 3-Shepard-Turner
        130    0.50   2.50  3♣ W +1   ♦5  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        130    0.50   2.50  2♣ W +2   ♦5  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠QT
♥AJ5
♦Q987643
♣6

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠AK43
♥9432
♦2
♣K932

♠9652
♥QT87
♦A5
♣QT8

♠J87
♥K6
♦KJT
♣AJ754

	9
10		8
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1/-♣ 4♦ 1NT ♣7/6 ♥5 ♠4

EW: 2♥ 1♠ ♣6 ♦3 NT4

LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: +130 4♦-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  660          3.00   0.00  3N S +2   ♠3  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
  150          2.00   1.00  1♦ N +4   ♥7  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 3-Shepard-Turner
  130          1.00   2.00  3♦ N +1   ♦A  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        300    0.00   3.00  3♣ S -3   ♠A  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura

♠3
♥A85
♦Q6
♣T987654

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠AQ7542
♥Q64
♦94
♣AJ

♠K986
♥K732
♦A732
♣K

♠JT
♥JT9
♦KJT85
♣Q32

	6
13		13
	8

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ ♦6 ♥3 ♠3 NT3

EW: 1♦ 3♥ 4♠ 4NT ♣5

LoTT: 18 - 20 = -2
Par: -430 4NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        420    3.00   0.00  4♠ W      ♣T  8-Rankin-Cogdill vs 7-Zaman-Kitamura
        450    1.00   2.00  5♠ E      ♣T  1-Charlotte-Gestiehr vs 3-Shepard-Turner
        450    1.00   2.00  4♠ W +1   ♣T  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Lagodimos-Angione
        450    1.00   2.00  4♠ W +1   ♣T  4-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Chaganlal-Ciolli