May 18, 2016 Game Result

? Explanation of report features View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

Field strength: Mean: 355 MP Geomean: 116 MP
(based on 15 players, 1 non ACBL player ignored)

★ ★ ★ Masterpoint Winners ★ ★ ★
Partnership	Pct	Rank	MP
James Ciolli - Manu Chaganlal	59.52	1st A	0.80
Roy Shepard - Thomas Turner	57.94	2/3rd A	0.48
Anisuz Zaman - Hideki Kitamura	57.94	2/3rd A	0.48

EVENT>Wednesday Evening Pairs  |SESSION>Wednesday Eve|SECTION> E
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>May 18, 2016       |CLUB NO.>260323    | 05/18/2016 21:42
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> John Lagodimos  |RATING>Club Masterpoint (100%, 70% Open)|MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   31.5 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>None/200       |CLUB>Eastlake Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=5                           ,---,-------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |      Section      |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Manu Chaganlal         James Ciolli             A    1     .     37.50  59.52  0.80(A) 
 2 Judi Bunch             Hiroko Kitamura          A    .     .     29.00  46.03          
 3 Clarie Pratt           Jim Atkins               B    .     .     28.00  44.44          
 4 Thomas Turner          Roy Shepard              B   2/3   1/2    36.50  57.94  0.48(A) 
 5 John Peter Lagodimos   Kenneth Gestiehr         A    NE    .     25.00  39.68          
 6 Anisuz Zaman           Hideki Kitamura          B   2/3   1/2    36.50  57.94  0.48(A) 
 7 Doral Hunter           Fran Hunter              B    .     .     25.50  40.48          
 8 Bill Osgood            Dave Cleary              B    .     .     34.00  53.97          
                                          Totals                   252.00

♠A6
♥QJ96
♦976
♣AQ74

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠T53
♥74
♦53
♣KJ9852

♠J8742
♥AK82
♦K82
♣3

♠KQ9
♥T53
♦AQJT4
♣T6

	13
4		11
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 4♦ 5♥ 2♠ 5NT

EW: ♣5 ♦2 ♥2 ♠4 NT2

LoTT: 14 - 16 = -2
Par: +460 5NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  490          3.00   0.00  3N S +3   ♣8  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Turner-Shepard
  460          2.00   1.00  3N S +2   ♠T  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
  400          1.00   2.00  3N N      ♠8  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
        100    0.00   3.00  3N S -2   ♠T  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠T2
♥AQ42
♦T82
♣AK75

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠73
♥98763
♦AK6
♣T93

♠KJ8
♥JT5
♦J95
♣QJ84

♠AQ9654
♥K
♦Q743
♣62

	13
7		9
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 4♦ 2♥ 5♠ 5NT

EW: ♣5/4 ♦3 ♥5 ♠2 NT2

LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +660 5NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          3.00   0.00  4♠ S +1   ♦A  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Turner-Shepard
  200          2.00   1.00  2♠ N +3   ♦A  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
  140          1.00   2.00  3♠ S      ♦A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        100    0.00   3.00  4♠ S -1   ♦K  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 7-Hunter-Hunter

♠AKJ98
♥KJT6
♦T7
♣74

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠642
♥A
♦AJ6
♣AQJ953

♠T7
♥8754
♦Q98532
♣8

♠Q53
♥Q932
♦K4
♣KT62

	12
16		2
	10

Double Dummy Makes

NS: -/2♥ 1/2♠
♣4/5 ♦1/2 ♥6/8 NT4/6

EW: 2♣ 5♦ ♥5 ♠4 NT4

LoTT: 19 - 17 = +2
Par: -500 5♠*-S/5♥*-S-3

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         50    1.50   1.50  4♠ S -1   ♣8  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
         50    1.50   1.50  4♠ N -1   ♣8  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Turner-Shepard
         50    1.50   1.50  4♠ N -1   ♣8  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
         50    1.50   1.50  3♠ N -1   ♣8  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠AKQT
♥AT75
♦-
♣QJ752

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠J873
♥J93
♦QT943
♣3

♠54
♥Q6
♦KJ652
♣T986

♠962
♥K842
♦A87
♣AK4

	16
4		6
	14

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 6♣ 6♥ 6♠ 6NT ♦6

EW: -/1♦ ♣1 ♦6/7 ♥1 ♠1 NT1

LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: +1440 6NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1470          3.00   0.00  6N N +1   ♦5  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
  680          1.00   2.00  4♥ S +2   ♣3  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  680          1.00   2.00  4♥ S +2   ♣3  4-Turner-Shepard vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  680          1.00   2.00  4♥ S +2   ♣3  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura

♠AK62
♥K983
♦62
♣QJ6

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠QJT8
♥AT
♦AKQJ3
♣K3

♠95
♥7654
♦T974
♣942

♠743
♥QJ2
♦85
♣AT875

	13
20		0
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 1/2♥ ♦4 ♠6 NT6

EW: 3♦ 1NT ♣4 ♥5 ♠6

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: -110 3♦-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  3N W -2   ♣Q  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
        110    2.00   1.00  3♦ W      ♠A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        130    0.50   2.50  3♦ W +1   ♣Q  4-Turner-Shepard vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        130    0.50   2.50  3♦ W +1   ♣Q  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Hunter-Hunter

♠KJ43
♥K7
♦KT6
♣KQ86

Dlr: East
Vul: E-W

♠AQ976
♥9643
♦9
♣754

♠82
♥Q85
♦QJ543
♣AT2

♠T5
♥AJT2
♦A872
♣J93

	15
6		9
	10

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 4♦ 5♥ 3♠ 5NT

EW: ♣2 ♦3 ♥2 ♠4 NT2

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: +460 5NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  490          3.00   0.00  3N N +3   ♦5  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
  460          2.00   1.00  3N N +2   ♦4  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  400          1.00   2.00  3N N      ♠8  4-Turner-Shepard vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  180          0.00   3.00  2N N +2   ♦5  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr

♠92
♥J843
♦A763
♣Q53

Dlr: South
Vul: Both

♠A873
♥52
♦QJ
♣KT872

♠JT4
♥AKT6
♦KT84
♣64

♠KQ65
♥Q97
♦952
♣AJ9

	7
10		11
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦4 ♥5 ♠4 NT4

EW: 2♣ 2♦ 2♥ 3♠ 3/2NT

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: -600 3NT-E

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.50   0.50  3♦ E -1   ♠K  4-Turner-Shepard vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          2.50   0.50  3♣ E -1   ♦2  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
    PASS       1.00   2.00  Pass Out      8-Osgood-Cleary vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        140    0.00   3.00  1♠ W +2   ♦6  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠AQ72
♥94
♦QT64
♣K54

Dlr: West
Vul: None

♠863
♥AQJT53
♦973
♣8

♠JT
♥K
♦KJ85
♣AQJT97

♠K954
♥8762
♦A2
♣632

	11
7		15
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♠ ♣4 ♦3 ♥3 NT5

EW: 3♣ 2♦ 4♥ 2NT ♠6

LoTT: 17 - 15 = +2
Par: -420 4♥-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          2.50   0.50  3N E -1   ♠4  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
   50          2.50   0.50  3♣ E -1   ♠4  4-Turner-Shepard vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
        150    1.00   2.00  3♣ E +2   ♦A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        170    0.00   3.00  2♥ W +2   ♦6  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura

♠AK8642
♥JT85
♦J6
♣8

Dlr: North
Vul: E-W

♠Q7
♥KQ4
♦KQ875
♣K93

♠JT95
♥A9
♦94
♣AT542

♠3
♥7632
♦AT32
♣QJ76

	9
15		9
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦4 ♥6 ♠6 NT4

EW: 3♣ 3♦ 1♥ 1♠ 3NT

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -600 3NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.00   1.00  3N W -1   ♠A  4-Turner-Shepard vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          2.00   1.00  3♦ W -1   ♠A  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  100          2.00   1.00  3♦ W -1   ♠A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        100    0.00   3.00  2♠ N -2   ♦9  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli

♠AKQ542
♥KQT92
♦9
♣J

Dlr: East
Vul: Both

♠986
♥AJ86
♦A
♣AQ954

♠T7
♥5
♦KQJ6532
♣T73

♠J3
♥743
♦T874
♣K862

	15
15		6
	4

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3/4♥ 2♠ 1NT ♣1/2 ♦2

EW: 4♣ 4♦ ♥3 ♠4 NT3/4

LoTT: 20 - 16 = +4
Par: +200 5♦*-EW/5♣*-EW-1

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  140          3.00   0.00  3♠ N      ♦K  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Turner-Shepard
        100    1.50   1.50  4♠ N -1   ♦K  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
        100    1.50   1.50  4♥ N -1   ♦K  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        200    0.00   3.00  4♠* N -1      1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura

♠984
♥K543
♦532
♣T92

Dlr: South
Vul: None

♠JT32
♥T82
♦AK7
♣A84

♠A765
♥QJ7
♦QT
♣K763

♠KQ
♥A96
♦J9864
♣QJ5

	3
12		12
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: ♣4 ♦6 ♥5 ♠4 NT4

EW: 3♣ 1♦ 2♥ 3♠ 3NT

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -400 3NT-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  4♠ W -2   ♠9  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        140    1.50   1.50  2♠ W +1   ♥2  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        140    1.50   1.50  1♠ W +2   ♦2  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Turner-Shepard
        400    0.00   3.00  3N E      ♦6  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 7-Hunter-Hunter

♠AT86
♥-
♦87652
♣QJ75

Dlr: West
Vul: N-S

♠Q42
♥K9876
♦KJ
♣643

♠J7
♥AQJT52
♦43
♣T92

♠K953
♥43
♦AQT9
♣AK8

	7
9		8
	16

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 5♣ 6♦ 5♠ 1NT ♥6

EW: 1♥ ♣2 ♦1 ♠2 NT6

LoTT: 19 - 20 = -1
Par: +1100 6♥*-EW-5

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          3.00   0.00  4♠ N +1   ♥A  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  170          2.00   1.00  3♠ N +1   ♥A  5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
  150          1.00   2.00  4♥ E -3   ♠K  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
  140          0.00   3.00  3♠ N      ♥A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Turner-Shepard

♠2
♥Q8
♦AQ92
♣KJ8762

Dlr: North
Vul: Both

♠JT93
♥AJ
♦JT8743
♣3

♠8764
♥KT75
♦K65
♣A4

♠AKQ5
♥96432
♦-
♣QT95

	12
7		10
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 4♣ 1♥ 2NT ♦6 ♠6

EW: 1♦ ♣1 ♥5 ♠6 NT4

LoTT: 17 - 19 = -2
Par: +130 4♣-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  950          3.00   0.00  5♣* N +1  ♦5  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  620          1.50   1.50  5♣ N +1   ♠8  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  620          1.50   1.50  5♣ N +1   ♦6  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
  130          0.00   3.00  2♦ N +2   ♦5  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Turner-Shepard

♠KQJ42
♥J8
♦6
♣AKQ54

Dlr: East
Vul: None

♠T
♥KQT7543
♦T5
♣T73

♠A63
♥96
♦AQJ83
♣J82

♠9875
♥A2
♦K9742
♣96

	16
5		12
	7

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♣ 1♦ 5♠ 2NT ♥5

EW: 2♥ ♣2 ♦5 ♠2 NT3

LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: +450 5♠-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  500          3.00   0.00  5♥* E -3  ♣Q  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
  450          2.00   1.00  4♠ N +1   ♥9  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  200          1.00   2.00  3♠ S +2   ♦5  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
  170          0.00   3.00  3♠ N +1   ♥6  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Turner-Shepard

♠QT72
♥AKJ2
♦987
♣AK

Dlr: South
Vul: N-S

♠K43
♥T98753
♦KT
♣J5

♠85
♥Q6
♦Q642
♣87643

♠AJ96
♥4
♦AJ53
♣QT92

	17
7		4
	12

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3/4♣ 4♦ 2/3♥ 5♠ 5NT

EW: ♣3 ♦3 ♥4 ♠1 NT2

LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: +660 5NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1430          3.00   0.00  6♠ S      ♥T  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  680          2.00   1.00  4♠ S +2   ♥7  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Turner-Shepard
  630          1.00   2.00  3N N +1   ♠8  6-Zaman-Kitamura vs 1-Chaganlal-Ciolli
        100    0.00   3.00  6♠ S -1   ♥T  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Pratt-Atkins

♠62
♥QT92
♦A763
♣A92

Dlr: West
Vul: E-W

♠K43
♥AJ6
♦Q82
♣JT87

♠Q987
♥753
♦JT5
♣K65

♠AJT5
♥K84
♦K94
♣Q43

	10
11		6
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ 3♦ 3♥ 2♠ 3NT

EW: ♣5 ♦4 ♥4 ♠5/4 NT4

LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: +400 3NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  120          3.00   0.00  1N S +1   ♣7  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  110          2.00   1.00  2♦ S +1       7-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
         50    0.50   2.50  3N N -1   ♦J  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 4-Turner-Shepard
         50    0.50   2.50  2♦ S -1   ♣J  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura

♠54
♥KJ72
♦Q2
♣98765

Dlr: North
Vul: None

♠KJ
♥AQ85
♦K3
♣QJT32

♠QT97
♥T943
♦T987
♣K

♠A8632
♥6
♦AJ654
♣A4

	6
16		5
	13

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 1♦ 1♠ ♣6 ♥5 NT6

EW: 1♣ 2♥ 1NT ♦6 ♠6

LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: -100 2♠*-NS-1

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.50   0.50  4♥ E -2   ♣A  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          2.50   0.50  3♥ W -2   ♦Q  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
   50          1.00   2.00  3♥ E -1   ♠A  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        110    0.00   3.00  2♥ E      ♣A  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 4-Turner-Shepard

♠K952
♥AT4
♦-
♣AJT532

Dlr: East
Vul: N-S

♠QJ63
♥K862
♦952
♣76

♠T7
♥J97
♦QJT863
♣Q9

♠A84
♥Q53
♦AK74
♣K84

	12
6		6
	16

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 6♣ 2♦ 3♥ 6♠ 6NT

EW: ♣1 ♦5 ♥4 ♠1 NT1

LoTT: 17 - 18 = -1
Par: +1440 6NT-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  660          3.00   0.00  3N S +2   ♠3  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  170          2.00   1.00  3♣ N +3   ♦Q  7-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  150          1.00   2.00  3♦ E -3   ♥3  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    0.00   3.00  5♣ S -1   ♦J  3-Pratt-Atkins vs 4-Turner-Shepard

♠KT9654
♥8
♦Q87
♣764

Dlr: South
Vul: E-W

♠AQ
♥AJ976
♦AJ42
♣T8

♠J72
♥T532
♦KT93
♣A2

♠83
♥KQ4
♦65
♣KQJ953

	5
16		8
	11

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♣ ♦2 ♥3 ♠6 NT3

EW: 4♦ 4♥ 1♠ 1NT ♣5

LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: -500 5♣*-NS-3

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  4♥ W -1   ♣4  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
        100    2.00   1.00  5♣* S -1  ♥A  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        140    1.00   2.00  3♥ W      ♣7  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
        620    0.00   3.00  4♥ W      ♠6  4-Turner-Shepard vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr

♠K9632
♥AT97
♦K5
♣K6

Dlr: West
Vul: Both

♠QJ8
♥J432
♦AJ
♣AJ83

♠A
♥K86
♦QT7643
♣Q72

♠T754
♥Q5
♦982
♣T954

	13
14		11
	2

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 2♠ ♣4 ♦3 ♥5 NT4

EW: 3♣ 4♦ 2♥ 2NT ♠5

LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: -130 4♦-EW

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.50   0.50  3N W -1   ♠3  4-Turner-Shepard vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  100          2.50   0.50  5♦ E -1   ♠7  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
        130    0.50   2.50  3♦ E +1   ♠T  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Pratt-Atkins
        130    0.50   2.50  3♦ E +1   ♠T  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura

♠9
♥Q98652
♦K2
♣AQ98

Dlr: North
Vul: N-S

♠A42
♥74
♦QJT95
♣KT4

♠KT8
♥K3
♦A74
♣J7653

♠QJ7653
♥AJT
♦863
♣2

	11
10		11
	8

Double Dummy Makes

NS: 3♥ 1♠ ♣5 ♦5/4 NT6

EW: 1♣ 2♦ ♥3 ♠5 NT5

LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +140 3♥-NS

  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          3.00   0.00  4♥ N +1       4-Turner-Shepard vs 5-Lagodimos-Gestiehr
  140          2.00   1.00  3♥ N      ♣7  8-Osgood-Cleary vs 7-Hunter-Hunter
        100    0.50   2.50  4♥ N -1   ♣3  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Zaman-Kitamura
        100    0.50   2.50  2♥ N -1   ♣5  1-Chaganlal-Ciolli vs 3-Pratt-Atkins