? Explanation of report features   View original ACBLscore output
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Field strength:  Mean: 418 MP  Geomean: 102 MP
(based on 16 players)
★ ★ ★  Masterpoint Winners  ★ ★ ★
Partnership Pct Rank MP
Hiroko Kitamura - Judi Bunch 64.29 1st A 0.80
Anisuz Zaman - Hideki Kitamura 57.94 2nd A 0.56
Carol Adair - Cheryl Rankin 46.83 3/4th A 0.34
Doral Hunter - Fran Hunter 46.83 3/4th A 0.34
Chad Heatherly - Merle Schneidewind 45.24 1st C 0.18
EVENT>Wednesday Evening Pairs  |SESSION>Wednesday Eve|SECTION> E
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>September 21, 2016 |CLUB NO.>260323    | 09/21/2016 21:51
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> John Lagodimos  |RATING>Club Masterpoint (100%, 80%, 60% Open)|MOVEMENT>ONE WINNER
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   31.5 |TOP>   3 |MP LIMITS>None/300/100   |CLUB>Eastlake Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=8/B=6/C=3                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Cheryl Rankin          Carol Adair              B   3/4   2/3    .     29.50  46.83  0.34(A) 
 2 Judi Bunch             Hiroko Kitamura          A    1     .     .     40.50  64.29  0.80(A) 
 3 Anisuz Zaman           Hideki Kitamura          B    2     1     .     36.50  57.94  0.56(A) 
 4 Kathy Crail            Bockman Charlotte        C    .     .     .     19.50  30.95          
 5 Kathie Angione         John Peter Lagodimos     A    NE    .     .     40.50  64.29          
 6 Chad Heatherly         Merle Schneidewind       C    .     .     1     28.50  45.24  0.18(C) 
 7 Bill Osgood            Dave Cleary              C    .     .     .     27.50  43.65          
 8 Fran Hunter            Doral Hunter             B   3/4   2/3    .     29.50  46.83  0.34(A) 
                                          Totals                         252.00       

Hands and Results
1 ♠854
♥QT
♦AT54
♣K432
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠972
♥A96432
♦Q2
♣AQ
♠AJT63
♥J85
♦76
♣JT8
♠KQ
♥K7
♦KJ983
♣9765
9
127
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 3♦  ♥5 ♠5 NT6
EW: 2♥ 2♠  ♣4 ♦4 NT6
LoTT: 17 - 18 = -1
Par: +100 3♠*-EW/3♥*-EW-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  130          3.00   0.00  3♦ S +1   ♥4  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
   50          2.00   1.00  2♥ W -1   ♦A  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        110    1.00   2.00  2♠ E      ♦9  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        140    0.00   3.00  3♥ E      ♦A  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
2 ♠-
♥AQT532
♦J92
♣Q982
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠AQT65
♥86
♦AK3
♣K76
♠J83
♥K9
♦87654
♣AJ4
♠K9742
♥J74
♦QT
♣T53
9
169
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥  ♣4 ♦2 ♠2 NT2
EW: 2♣ 5♦ 5♠ 4NT  ♥6
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: -450 5♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.00   0.00  2N W -1   ♥5  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
        140    2.00   1.00  3♠ W      ♦J  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        170    1.00   2.00  3♠ W +1   ♥A  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        420    0.00   3.00  4♠ E      ♣2  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
3 ♠A6
♥K2
♦AKT
♣KJ7643
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠KJ75
♥AJ6
♦Q7652
♣T
♠T983
♥Q
♦J94
♣Q9852
♠Q42
♥T987543
♦83
♣A
18
115
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 4♥  ♦5/6 ♠5 NT6
EW: 1♦ 2♠ 1NT  ♣6 ♥2
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +420 4♥-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          2.50   0.50  4♥ S +1   ♠5  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
  450          2.50   0.50  4♥ S +1   ♣T  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
  420          1.00   2.00  4♥ S      ♣T  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        100    0.00   3.00  3N N -2   ♠T  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
4 ♠7
♥J874
♦AT98743
♣K
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠AQ42
♥K52
♦65
♣A852
♠JT9
♥93
♦KQJ
♣QJT74
♠K8653
♥AQT6
♦2
♣963
8
1310
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦ 1♥  ♣2 ♠4 NT2
EW: 4♣ 2♠ 3NT  ♦5 ♥3
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: -500 4♦*-NS-2
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  110          3.00   0.00  3♦ N      ♣Q  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        110    2.00   1.00  2♣ W +1   ♠7  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        200    1.00   2.00  3♦* N -1  ♣Q  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
        500    0.00   3.00  4♦* N -2  ♣Q  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 1-Rankin-Adair
5 ♠QT6542
♥42
♦T42
♣T6
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠A9873
♥A9
♦AQ7
♣J97
♠K
♥KJT753
♦K6
♣AKQ4
♠J
♥Q86
♦J9853
♣8532
2
1519
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣0 ♦2 ♥0 ♠2 NT0
EW: 7♣ 5♦ 7♥ 5♠ 7NT
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -1520 7NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        480    3.00   0.00  4♥ E +2   ♠J  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        490    2.00   1.00  3N E +3   ♦5  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        520    1.00   2.00  3N W +4   ♥4  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
        980    0.00   3.00  6♥ E      ♠J  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
6 ♠AQT984
♥98
♦A982
♣5
Dlr: East
Vul: E-W
♠K32
♥AJT3
♦64
♣KQJ7
♠J76
♥K642
♦QJ75
♣A4
♠5
♥Q75
♦KT3
♣T98632
10
1411
5
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♦ 2♠  ♣6 ♥3 NT4
EW: 1♣ 2♥ 3NT  ♦5 ♠5
LoTT: 16 - 15 = +1
Par: -300 4♠*-NS-2
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  530          3.00   0.00  3♠* N     ♣A  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
  200          2.00   1.00  4♥ E -2   ♠5  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 1-Rankin-Adair
  100          1.00   2.00  3♥ W -1   ♣5  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        170    0.00   3.00  3♥ W +1   ♣5  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
7 ♠KQT52
♥A52
♦AQ
♣743
Dlr: South
Vul: Both
♠3
♥Q8763
♦K94
♣AJ96
♠74
♥KJT9
♦J752
♣KQT
♠AJ986
♥4
♦T863
♣852
15
1010
5
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♠ 2NT  ♣5 ♦6 ♥4
EW: 2/3♥  ♣6 ♦6 ♠3 NT5
LoTT: 19 - 19 = 0
Par: +500 5♥*-W-2
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          3.00   0.00  4♠ N +1   ♥J  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
  620          1.00   2.00  4♠ N      ♥J  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Rankin-Adair
  620          1.00   2.00  4♠ N      ♥9  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  620          1.00   2.00  4♠ N      ♦2  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
8 ♠J875
♥AQ82
♦K85
♣Q2
Dlr: West
Vul: None
♠AQ2
♥94
♦AQJ6
♣KJ94
♠KT4
♥KT53
♦T32
♣AT3
♠963
♥J76
♦974
♣8765
12
1710
1
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣2 ♦2 ♥4 ♠3 NT2
EW: 5♣ 5♦ 3♥ 4♠ 4NT
LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: -430 4NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        400    2.50   0.50  3N W      ♠8  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        400    2.50   0.50  3N W      ♠5  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
        460    0.50   2.50  4N E +1   ♣6  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
        460    0.50   2.50  3N W +2   ♥2  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Rankin-Adair
9 ♠Q865
♥KT9
♦J63
♣K64
Dlr: North
Vul: E-W
♠7
♥A543
♦A5
♣QJT853
♠A943
♥872
♦Q872
♣97
♠KJT2
♥QJ6
♦KT94
♣A2
9
116
14
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦ 1♥ 4♠ 1NT  ♣5
EW: 2♣  ♦4 ♥6 ♠3 NT4
LoTT: 18 - 16 = +2
Par: +420 4♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  2♣ W -1   ♥9  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
         50    2.00   1.00  2♠ S -1   ♠7  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        100    1.00   2.00  2N N -2   ♣9  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        110    0.00   3.00  3♣ W      ♦3  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
10 ♠AJ
♥Q3
♦QJ3
♣KT7654
Dlr: East
Vul: Both
♠K5
♥AKJT2
♦862
♣Q92
♠Q98762
♥7
♦KT54
♣83
♠T43
♥98654
♦A97
♣AJ
13
135
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 1NT  ♦6 ♥6 ♠5
EW: 1♠  ♣4 ♦6 ♥6 NT4
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +110 3♣-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  130          3.00   0.00  3♣ N +1   ♥7  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
  110          2.00   1.00  2♣ N +1       5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
   90          1.00   2.00  2♣ N      ♥7  1-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        500    0.00   3.00  3N N -5   ♠9  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
11 ♠432
♥96
♦8752
♣T754
Dlr: South
Vul: None
♠KT86
♥5
♦A63
♣AKJ92
♠QJ5
♥Q74
♦KQT9
♣863
♠A97
♥AKJT832
♦J4
♣Q
0
1510
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♥  ♣2 ♦2 ♠3 NT3
EW: 4♣ 4♦ 4♠ 2/-NT
       ♥6/5 NT8/5
LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: -420 4♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  110          3.00   0.00  2♥ S      ♣A  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
        130    2.00   1.00  4♣ W      ♥9  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        150    1.00   2.00  4♥ S -3   ♣K  1-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        300    0.00   3.00  4♥* S -2  ♣K  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
12 ♠762
♥QT7532
♦A854
♣-
Dlr: West
Vul: N-S
♠5
♥AKJ4
♦QJ73
♣J954
♠AQJT943
♥9
♦T
♣AQ62
♠K8
♥86
♦K962
♣KT873
6
1213
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣3 ♦6 ♥6 ♠3 NT4
EW: 4♣ -/1♦ -/1♥ 3♠ 3NT
       ♦6/7 ♥6/7
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -400 3NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          2.50   0.50  5♠ E -2   ♥6  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
  100          2.50   0.50  4♠ E -2   ♥8  5-Angione-Lagodimos vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        170    1.00   2.00  2♠ E +2   ♥8  1-Rankin-Adair vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        200    0.00   3.00  3♠ E +2   ♦3  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
13 ♠732
♥AQJ2
♦AQ86
♣Q7
Dlr: North
Vul: Both
♠AJT95
♥73
♦T4
♣A986
♠K4
♥954
♦KJ752
♣T53
♠Q86
♥KT86
♦93
♣KJ42
15
97
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♥  ♣6/5 ♦5 ♠5 NT6
EW: 1♣ 2♦ 1♠  ♥5 NT6
LoTT: 16 - 15 = +1
Par: +110 2♥-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          3.00   0.00  4♥ N      ♦5  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
  110          2.00   1.00  2♥ S      ♦T  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
        200    0.50   2.50  4♥ S -2   ♠A  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
        200    0.50   2.50  4♥ N -2   ♦7  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 1-Rankin-Adair
14 ♠87
♥T432
♦A3
♣AKQ53
Dlr: East
Vul: None
♠J9432
♥AJ
♦KT92
♣42
♠KQT65
♥K865
♦Q75
♣J
♠A
♥Q97
♦J864
♣T9876
13
911
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 1♥ 1NT  ♦5 ♠3
EW: 2♦ 3♠  ♣4 ♥6 NT6
LoTT: 18 - 20 = -2
Par: -100 4♣*-NS-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         50    3.00   0.00  4♣ N -1   ♠K  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
        170    2.00   1.00  3♠ E +1   ♣T  6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 1-Rankin-Adair
        420    0.50   2.50  4♠ W      ♣A  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
        420    0.50   2.50  4♠ E      ♣7  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
15 ♠Q762
♥K874
♦K73
♣QT
Dlr: South
Vul: N-S
♠AK93
♥J52
♦QT2
♣A62
♠T854
♥T9
♦AJ
♣J9874
♠J
♥AQ63
♦98654
♣K53
10
146
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦ 2♥  ♣5/4 ♠5 NT5
EW: 2♣ 2♠  ♦5 ♥5 NT6
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -110 2♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.00   0.00  3♠ E -2   ♠J  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
   50          2.00   1.00  2♠ E -1   ♣3  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
        110    0.50   2.50  2♠ E      ♥3  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
        110    0.50   2.50  2♠ E          6-Heatherly-Schneidewind vs 1-Rankin-Adair
16 ♠KQ643
♥2
♦AKJ432
♣8
Dlr: West
Vul: E-W
♠J9
♥A875
♦96
♣QJT93
♠AT875
♥-
♦Q8
♣AK6542
♠2
♥KQJT9643
♦T75
♣7
13
813
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♦ 4♥  ♣2 ♠5 NT5
EW: 4♣ 1♠ 1NT  ♦3 ♥3
LoTT: 20 - 20 = 0
Par: +200 5♣*-EW-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          2.50   0.50  4♥ S      ♣Q  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  420          2.50   0.50  4♥ S      ♣Q  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
         50    0.50   2.50  4♥ S -1   ♣3  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
         50    0.50   2.50  5♦ N -1   ♠A  1-Rankin-Adair vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
17 ♠T853
♥7
♦42
♣QT7652
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠A92
♥J9
♦KT765
♣843
♠J6
♥AQ83
♦J983
♣AJ9
♠KQ74
♥KT6542
♦AQ
♣K
2
813
17
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 1♠  ♦3 ♥6 NT5
EW: 3♦ 1/-♥ 2NT
       ♣5/4 ♥7/6 ♠5
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -110 3♦-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          3.00   0.00  4♠ S      ♣A  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
    PASS       2.00   1.00  Pass Out      8-Hunter-Hunter vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
        110    0.50   2.50  3♦ W      ♥5  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
        110    0.50   2.50  3♦ E      ♠K  1-Rankin-Adair vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
18 ♠A96
♥K9642
♦Q92
♣J2
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠T72
♥J7
♦J8
♣KQ9876
♠KJ5
♥AT3
♦T7643
♣T5
♠Q843
♥Q85
♦AK5
♣A43
10
78
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♦ 3♥ 2♠ 3NT  ♣6
EW: 1♣  ♦5 ♥4 ♠4 NT4
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +500 4♣*-EW-3
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  150          2.50   0.50  2N S +1   ♦8  3-Zaman-Kitamura vs 4-Crail-Charlotte
  150          2.50   0.50  2N S +1   ♣8  7-Osgood-Cleary vs 2-Bunch-Kitamura
  140          1.00   2.00  2♥ N +1   ♣T  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
        200    0.00   3.00  4♥ S -2   ♣K  1-Rankin-Adair vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
19 ♠97
♥9752
♦J643
♣J76
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠T654
♥AQJ
♦5
♣A9842
♠Q82
♥KT84
♦AQ97
♣T3
♠AKJ3
♥63
♦KT82
♣KQ5
2
1111
16
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♦  ♣6 ♥5 ♠5 NT5
EW: 1♣ 2♥ 2♠ 1NT  ♦6
LoTT: 15 - 15 = 0
Par: -110 2♠-EW/2♥-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         90    3.00   0.00  1N E      ♠3  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        100    2.00   1.00  1N S -2   ♣4  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
        120    0.50   2.50  2N E      ♠A  1-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
        120    0.50   2.50  2N E      ♠A  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
20 ♠KJT876
♥A9
♦8
♣T863
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠9
♥KJ7
♦AKT632
♣AK4
♠A52
♥QT6542
♦Q4
♣Q5
♠Q43
♥83
♦J975
♣J972
8
1810
4
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♠  ♣5 ♦1 ♥1 NT1
EW: 1♣ 6♦ 6♥ 4NT  ♠6
LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: -1400 6♠*-NS-5
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        230    3.00   0.00  3♥ E +3   ♠Q  8-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        680    1.50   1.50  4♥ E +2   ♠Q  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
        680    1.50   1.50  4♥ E +2   ♠3  1-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura
       1430    0.00   3.00  6♥ E      ♠3  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
21 ♠AK7
♥AK2
♦T8
♣AK963
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠QJT963
♥73
♦7652
♣5
♠542
♥QT964
♦3
♣QT72
♠8
♥J85
♦AKQJ94
♣J84
21
34
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 6♣ 7♦ 4/3♥ 3♠ 7NT
EW:  ♣1 ♦0 ♥3 ♠4 NT0
LoTT: 17 - 17 = 0
Par: +2220 7NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1470          3.00   0.00  6N N +1   ♠6  2-Bunch-Kitamura vs 6-Heatherly-Schneidewind
 1440          2.00   1.00  6N N      ♥T  4-Crail-Charlotte vs 5-Angione-Lagodimos
    PASS       1.00   2.00  Pass Out      8-Hunter-Hunter vs 7-Osgood-Cleary
        100    0.00   3.00  6♦ S -1   ♣5  1-Rankin-Adair vs 3-Zaman-Kitamura